The world’s #1 Guide to Scholarships and Financial Aid

7.4. Gathering Letters of Recommendation

Letters of recommendation are a vital piece of your scholarship application puzzle—they offer a third-party perspective that validates your accomplishments, character, and potential in a way your essay or transcript can’t. A strong letter can tip the scales in your favor, while a weak or generic one might drag you down. Here’s how to secure compelling letters and choose the right recommenders to make your application shine.

Scholarship committees rely on these letters to get an outside take on who you are beyond the numbers and self-reported stories. A recommender who can vouch for your work ethic, resilience, or creativity adds credibility that’s hard to fake. Many scholarships require one or two letters, often from teachers, employers, or mentors, so treat this step as a chance to amplify your case—not just a box to check.

How to Get Great Letters

• Choose Wisely: Quality Over Clout. The best recommenders aren’t always the most impressive titles—they’re the people who know you deeply. A teacher who’s watched you evolve over years, a coach who’s seen you lead under pressure, or a boss who can detail your initiative trumps a distant VIP every time. For example, if your calculus teacher can write about how you stayed after class to master tough concepts, that’s gold—way more impactful than a vague note from a superintendent who only knows your name from a roster. Match the recommender to the scholarship’s focus, too: a STEM award might favor your science teacher, while a community service scholarship could lean on your volunteer coordinator.

• Ask Early: Respect Their Time. Timing is critical. Approach your recommenders at least 3–4 weeks before the deadline—earlier if possible. Last-minute requests can lead to lukewarm, hastily written letters that lack depth. Springing it on someone a day before risks them saying no or churning out something generic like “They’re a good student.” Give them breathing room to reflect and craft something meaningful. If it’s around a busy season (like end-of-term grading), pad that timeline even more.

• Provide Context: Set Them Up for Success. Don’t leave your recommender guessing about what to say. Arm them with tools to make their letter specific and relevant. Share:

• The scholarship’s name, mission, and criteria (e.g., “It’s for future engineers who show innovation”).

• Your resume or a list of achievements (grades, projects, extracurriculars).

• A few key traits or moments you’d love highlighted—like how you organized a fundraiser or bounced back from a setback. For instance, you might say, “Could you mention how I led the debate team to nationals? It ties to my goal of becoming a lawyer.” This isn’t dictating their letter—it’s giving them a lens to focus their thoughts. If it’s a digital submission, provide clear instructions or a link; if it’s physical, offer a stamped, addressed envelope.

• Follow Up: Stay on Track. Recommenders are human—deadlines can slip their minds. A polite check-in a week before it’s due (“Just wanted to see if you need anything else from me!”) keeps things moving without nagging. Confirm how they’ll submit it—some scholarships require them to send it directly, while others let you collect it. If it’s the latter, arrange a pickup time or method. A gentle nudge shows you’re organized, not pushy.

• Say Thanks: Build Bridges. After they’ve submitted, don’t ghost them. A handwritten thank-you note or a sincere email (“I really appreciate your time—it means a lot to my future”) goes a long way. It’s not just polite—it keeps the door open for future requests, like college apps or another scholarship down the line. Small gestures like a coffee shop gift card can sweeten the deal, but the gratitude itself is what counts.

How to Choose the Right Recommenders

Pick People Who Know You Well. Depth beats dazzle. A professor who’s mentored your research, a supervisor who’s watched you juggle shifts and school, or a mentor who’s guided your passion project can write with authority and specificity. Avoid someone who only knows you casually—they’ll struggle to say more than “They’re nice.” Ask yourself: Can this person tell a story about me that proves I’m scholarship material?

• Match Their Insight to the Scholarship. Think strategically. If the scholarship prizes academic grit, your toughest teacher might highlight how you aced their class. For leadership, a club advisor could detail your impact. The closer their experience with you aligns with the award’s values, the stronger their endorsement. If possible, diversify your recommenders (e.g., one academic, one professional) to show your well-roundedness—check the scholarship’s rules first, though.

• Gauge Their Enthusiasm. A lukewarm letter hurts more than it helps. When asking, frame it as an invitation: “I’m applying for this scholarship and thought you’d be a great fit to recommend me—would you be comfortable writing a letter?” If they hesitate or seem unenthusiastic, pivot to someone else. You want a recommender who’s genuinely excited to sing your praises.

• Test Their Writing Ability (Subtly). A glowing letter won’t land if it’s poorly written. If you’ve seen their communication style—like a teacher’s feedback or a boss’s emails—you’ll have a sense of their clarity. You can’t edit their work, so pick someone who can articulate your strengths professionally. If you’re unsure, context clues (like their role or education level) can hint at their skill.

Letters of recommendation are your cheerleaders on paper—they humanize your application and back up your claims with credibility. Invest time in choosing the right people and supporting them well, and you’ll turn a requirement into a standout asset. A thoughtful, detailed letter can echo your essay’s themes, painting a cohesive picture of a candidate who’s not just qualified, but unforgettable.